Oh dear Lord, what a commentary! This track is on par with the Michael Jeck commentary for Seven Samurai, but it's only available on Criterion's laserdisc. The film's scholar, Howard Suber, takes you through all aspects of the production and script, from the significances of harsh and soft lighting, to the elements which are NOT in focus, to the overall arch of Benjamin's character. Once you hear this track by Howard Suber, you'll want to hear his others. This is an absolute must-listen for any student of film. RATED TEN.

Yes, I agree that this is an excellent commentary and that it should be revived on DVD from laserdisc. In addition to what is said by the other reviewer, Suber makes some very interesting comments about the film as a comedy, such as that the hero in comedy goes from being passive to being active at some point in the narrative (reached here when Benjamin tells his parents about marrying Elaine: "It's a decision I've made"). The popping toast emphasizes his point.

This is the commentary that all other commentaries should be measured by. Unlike many of the commentaries I've heard, he comes very well prepared and shows complete control and enthusiasm. His timing, lenght and selection of comments are spot on. Perfect! 10/10