Login | Register
(e.g., Lord of the Rings, or Joss Whedon, or director of photography)

Welcome to RateThatCommentary.com -- the definitive commentary track database, as well as your guide to finding the best and worst in DVD commentary tracks.

Newest Commentary Reviews RSS feed

March 25th: Caught Up by frankasu03, The Hitcher by frankasu03, Iron Man 2 by Hungry Baz, Iron Man 3 by Hungry Baz, Evil Dead by Hungry Baz, Zombieland by Hungry Baz, The Muppets by Hungry Baz, Easy A by Hungry Baz, Tropic Thunder by Hungry Baz, The World's End by Hungry Baz, Paul by Hungry Baz, 50/50 by Hungry Baz, Kick-Ass 2 by Hungry Baz. March 24th: Hell Up In Harlem by frankasu03, The Treasure of the Sierra Madre by badge

Current top 10 commentary tracks

These are the commentary tracks in the RateThatCommentary.com database that have gotten the highest user votes so far. To qualify for the list, a track has to have gotten at least five votes. Or, if you're more interested in tracks to avoid, check out the lowest-rated commentaries. The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp cover

1. The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp -- Commentary track: Director Michael Powell and filmmaker Martin Scorsese. Rating: 9.5

2. Paper Moon -- Commentary track: Director/producer Peter Bogdanovich. Rating: 9.2

3. Rounders -- Commentary track: Director John Dahl, screenwriters David Levien and Brian Koppelman, and actor Edward Norton. Rating: 9.2

4. Sarah Silverman: Jesus is Magic -- Commentary track: Director Liam Lynch and comedian Sarah Silverman. Rating: 9.2

5. They Live -- Commentary track: Roddy Piper and John Carpenter. Rating: 9.1

6. Peter Pan -- Commentary track: Producer Walt Disney (from archival recordings), host/producer's nephew Roy E. Disney, animators Frank Thomas, Ollie Johnston, Marc Davis, and Ward Kimball, film historians Leonard Maltin, John Canemaker, and Jeff Kurtti, Margaret Kerry, model for Tinkerbell, and Kathryn Beaumont, voice actor/model for Wendy . Rating: 9.0

7. What's Up, Doc? -- Commentary track: Director Peter Bogdanovich. Rating: 9.0

8. A Fistful of Dollars -- Commentary track: Sergio Leone expert Sir Christopher Frayling. Rating: 9.0

9. Network -- Commentary track: Director Sidney Lumet. Rating: 9.0

10. The Third Man -- Commentary track: Filmmaker Steven Soderbergh and screenwriter Tony Gilroy. Rating: 9.0

To see more, check out the top 100 commentary tracks list.